• Blog
  • The Rise of Craft Beer: Fine Ales to be Offered at Auction

The Rise of Craft Beer: Fine Ales to be Offered at Auction

Beer Auction | Samuel Adams Utopias 2007

Samuel Adams Utopias 2007, To be auctioned online October 31 – November 8 (Lot 540: Estimate $175-$275)

When a two-bottle lot of 2007 Samuel Adams Utopias goes up for auction on November 8, 2012, Skinner will become the first brick-and-mortar auction house in the US to offer beer at auction. With craft beer on the rise and aging beer a verifiable trend, we are confident that this category will certainly grow.

I have been following the rise of the craft beer world closely for the past five years ever since purchasing, for six dollars, a twelve ounce bottle of Goose Island Bourbon County Brand Stout. At the time, I thought I was either a sucker or that the bottle would have to be pretty darn good at fifty cents an ounce. It turned out the latter was the truth and the former was yet to be determined. On further inspection, I noticed that the bottle was vintage dated and the small print revealed that the brewer believed the beer would develop in the bottle for up to five years. So I bought a few more and tucked them away in my cellar with my Zind Humbrecht and Tignanello, hoping to forget them for a few years.

That was 2007. Last year I revisited that bottle in a vertical tasting of Bourbon County Brand Stout spanning 2006 through 2010. At separate tastings, I have sampled beers from 1972, 1977, 1989, several from the 1990s and several more from the 21st century. What I have learned is that certain styles of beer certainly do benefit from age while many others should be enjoyed fresh, not unlike wine where the vast majority of wine produced annually should be consumed within the first few years after bottling.

Of course there are major differences between beer and wine. Where the quality of wine is linked to the trinity of vintage, terroir and the skill of the winemaker, beer is almost exclusively linked to the skill of the brewer. Rather than a great vintage of a particular beer, there are great batches, as the brewer is not limited to a single crop of grains in a given year. And batches are small. Where Domaine de la Romanee Conti will produce about 500 cases of Romanee Conti each year, some of the most sought-after beers will release just a few hundred bottles, ever. Hill Farmstead’s Ann, for example, is regarded as one of the finest examples of saison ever made and only 160 bottles were released.

Samuel Adams Utopias 2007 | Beer Auction

A close up of Samuel Adams on the side of the bottle

The beer we’re offering at auction represents a pioneer in the craft beer world, much as Samuel Adams the patriot was a pioneer in his time. With just 12,000 bottles released bi-annually, production is roughly equivalent to that of the absurdly rare Chateau Le Pin, which releases 500-600 cases each year. With an alcohol content of approximately 24% by volume for its inaugural release in 2002, Utopias was the highest alcohol beer produced. Notably, this was achieved exclusively through fermentation using a blend of Champagne yeast and a proprietary yeast strain – without the use of freeze-distilling. The ale is extracted from a mash of four malts and brewed with noble hops, then aged in a variety of previously-used bourbon, rum, muscatel, sherry, brandy and Cognac casks before being blended into the final product. Each batch released has distinct characteristics as the casks develop. The 2007 batch, offered here, is the highest-alcohol batch to date, weighing in at 27%, an ale to be sipped, considered, discussed and shared rather than tipped back without thought.

With this lot, Skinner is proud to confirm that fine ales, lagers and lambics are welcome to be auctioned alongside fine wines and spirits. We look forward to offering more lots in 2013 and beyond. Contact us at finewines@skinnerinc.com or 508-970-3133 for more information or to discuss your collection of fine ales, lagers and lambics.

9 thoughts on “The Rise of Craft Beer: Fine Ales to be Offered at Auction

  1. Hello,
    I am located in Toronto, Canada but also have a residence in the USA. Is there any way I can bid on the sam adams utopias without going to the auction.


  2. Thanks to everyone for your interest in this lot. The auction was yesterday and I’m happy to report that the lot of two-bottle lot of 2007 Samuel Adams Utopias sold for $488 to a private US collector. Additionally, a single bottle lot of 2007 Samuel Adams Utopias sold in our Fine Wines Online auction for $244, again to a private US collector. We are looking forward to offering much more in 2013.


      • Hi John – Unfortunately the Utopias is no longer available. We hope to have more in the future. We will have a bottle of Sam Adams Millennium in the October 2015 Fine Wines & Spirits – Online auction; as you may know, Millennium was the precursor to Utopias. -MM

  3. I have a single bottle of 2007 Sam Adams Utopia Beer.
    I would like to put it up for auction. Could I contact you?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *